How to stop fake damage claims on Shopify
How fake damage claims work
Most fake claims reuse evidence that already exists. The four common methods:
- Reused photos from an earlier claim at your store or another store
- Borrowed photos found online or in a review
- Edited or AI-made damage added to a photo of an undamaged item
- Photos of a screen showing someone else's damaged item
Why email photo requests don't work
Asking for a photo by email accepts any image from the camera roll. That includes every method above. It also slows honest customers down with back and forth.
A verification process that works
- Live capture only. Send a link that opens a guided camera. How live capture works
- Photo of the shipping label. Match the tracking number to the order. Label check
- Product match. Compare the item with your catalogue images. Product check
- Reuse check. Compare each photo with past claims. Reuse check
- Editing and AI check. Score photos for generation and editing. AI check
- Screen check. Spot photos of monitors and printouts. Screen check
Keep honest customers happy
Never accuse. When a photo fails a check ask politely for one more live photo. Refund clear claims automatically under a set amount so most customers are paid in minutes.
Common questions
What is damage claim fraud
Damage claim fraud is when a customer asks for a refund or replacement for an item that wasn't really damaged in transit. Common methods are reusing an old photo or using a photo from the internet or editing damage in with an AI tool or photographing a screen.
How do I verify a damage claim on Shopify
Ask for live photos of the damage and the box and the shipping label. Check the label matches the order tracking. Check the item matches what was ordered. Check the photos haven't been used before or edited. pruvana does all of this automatically.
Should I just refund every damage claim
Refunding without checks is fast but it teaches repeat claimers that it works. A short live photo step keeps refunds fast for honest customers and stops most fake claims before money moves.
